TyronePA e-cafe - Tyrone Pennsylvania Community Forum

Hey all. My wife's Aunt Janet used to make smearcase. It was made with cottage chese and it resembled a pudding. I have searched for this on many websites and always was returned with a recipe for smearcase cake. This is not a cake and not what we are looking for . If anyone has this recipe, especially anyone in the Keefer or Snyder clan. please post or drop me a PM. Thanks

http://www.online-kitchen.com/blogs/node/803

This is all I could find. Hope it helps!

Thanks Mainegirl, But I guess that's not quite it. I'm not sure but I think this was sweet and had cinnamon in it. Could be she doctored hers in a unique way that made it memorable. thanks for trying though...

Hey all .. Just thought I'd post a follow-up, since I started this thread. My wife talked to a relative of her aunts and got the ingedient list for Smearcase but not the quantities. So I guess we'll have to play with it and see if we can match the taste she remembers.. Thanks to all for your suggestions and interest... If anyone's interested in our results let me know and i'll post them here...Rob :bluebounce:

I thought smearcase was just another name for cottage cheese. I know when I was young my gramma used to cream cottage cheese and add vanilla, cinnamon, sugar, and nutmeg to it and it was really good...she just always called it spiced-up smearcase...LOL